When I first heard someone claim ADHD was over-diagnosed, my immediate thought was: rubbish. The real reason for the apparent spike is obvious to anyone paying attention — the seismic shift from DSM-IV to DSM-5.
I’m going to make absolutely no apology for the length of this, because it needs a thorough explanation. When a lot of the statements that prompted this piece were made, I — like many others — was irritated. But once you actually look into it and identify the root cause, you realise not only that the claim is wrong, but that what we’re seeing was entirely foreseeable and predictable.
Grab a cup of tea or coffee, fill the kettle back up, maybe get a pack of biscuits — you might be here a while.
Over the last year we’ve seen a definite backslide in how neurodivergent conditions are discussed publicly. Autism and ADHD in particular have been frequent targets in the media. I’m not going to comment on what’s happening across the pond — partly because I prefer arguments that involve words of more than two syllables, and partly because I refuse to lower myself to that particular level of discourse.
What has been more concerning to me is hearing our own Health Secretary state, without qualification, that “ADHD is being over-diagnosed.” That statement is not just misleading — it is demonstrably false. I’ve seen thoughtful rebuttals from within the neurodivergent community and from clinicians, offering explanations such as increased awareness, reduced stigma (or at least less than there used to be), greater acceptance, and improved access to services. All of these are contributing factors, and none of them are wrong.
However, what most of these explanations fail to address is the single most important factor: improved diagnostics. And more specifically, a fundamental change in how neurodevelopmental conditions are classified. That shift occurred with the transition from DSM-IV to DSM-5 (American Psychiatric Association, 2013).
What makes this narrative particularly baffling is that even the data being cited points directly to the answer. We’re told — often with a tone of concern — that diagnoses and prescriptions began rising around thirteen years ago. Thirteen years. Entirely coincidentally, that places us squarely in the transition period leading up to DSM-5, published in 2013, following several years of consultation, draft revisions, and early adoption in clinical practice. At this point, the question isn’t why rates increased — it’s why anyone is still pretending this correlation is mysterious.
Which brings us to the part that rarely seems to be explained: what the DSM actually is, what it does, and why changes to it matter.
1. The DSM-IV model: categorisation by observable impairment
Before examining DSM-IV specifically, it’s important to be clear about what the DSM actually is. The DSM (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders) is not a biological discovery tool, a map of the brain, or a declaration of objective truth. It is a classification framework — a consensus document that defines how clinicians describe, group, and diagnose patterns of behaviour and cognition at a particular moment in time.
Put simply: the DSM does not create neurotypes. It decides what we call them, how narrowly or broadly we define them, and who is allowed through the diagnostic gate.
This distinction matters. When commentators point to rising ADHD diagnoses or medication use — often with a tone of alarm — while noting that the increase began over a decade ago, they are very close to the answer without quite seeing it. Change the rulebook, broaden criteria, remove exclusions, redefine what counts as clinically relevant, and the outcome is not mysterious. You don’t get an epidemic; you get people who were always there finally being recognised.
DSM-IV, which governed diagnosis until the publication of DSM-5 in 2013, was built on a fundamentally different organising principle from what we now understand as neurodivergence. It did not frame conditions in terms of difference, variation, or cognitive profile. Instead, it categorised disorders primarily by observable impairment — how visible, disruptive, and externally verifiable a person’s behaviour was to others.
Autism and ADHD were placed in separate diagnostic silos, with an explicit assumption of mutual exclusivity. If you met criteria for autism, ADHD was effectively ruled out, regardless of attentional regulation difficulties. This was not a scientific inevitability; it was a modelling choice.
For ADHD specifically, DSM-IV required:
- Clear functional impairment
- Symptoms present before the age of 7
- Evidence across multiple settings
- External corroboration, typically from parents or teachers
The emphasis throughout was not on internal cognitive experience, but on whether difficulties were sufficiently obvious to be noticed by the environment. What mattered most was not how a person processed information, regulated attention, or experienced cognitive load — but whether their behaviour caused problems that others could see.
This framework inevitably privileged early, externalised disruption and systematically disadvantaged those whose differences were internalised, masked, or context-dependent. It completely excluded many girls and women, whose presentations were often quiet, compliant, or otherwise internalised; and entire generations of adults who had not been disruptive in childhood or whose struggles had been masked, accommodated, or misinterpreted. It also laid the groundwork for the widespread exclusion of entire neurotypes that would later appear to “emerge” under DSM-5 — despite having always existed.
2. ADHD subtypes and the problem of invisibility
DSM-IV did technically recognise different ADHD subtypes, but in practice these distinctions reinforced the same bias.
The Predominantly Hyperactive-Impulsive presentation aligned neatly with the diagnostic model:
- Externalised behaviour
- Classroom disruption
- Behavioural visibility
- Immediate system impact
By contrast, the Predominantly Inattentive subtype — a name that is itself revealing — described individuals whose difficulties were largely internalised:
- Quiet
- Compliant
- Non-disruptive
- Often highly masking
- Struggling internally rather than behaviourally
This subtype was not just under-diagnosed; it was structurally disadvantaged by the model itself. “Inattentive” frames the issue from the observer’s point of view — as a failure to attend to what is expected — rather than recognising a fundamentally different mode of attentional regulation.
What this group often actually exhibits is:
- Interest-driven attention
- Hyperfocus when engaged
- Difficulty with low-salience or arbitrary tasks
- High internal cognitive activity with low external signalling
When combined with high intelligence, strong masking, compliance-based coping, internalised distress, and autistic traits, you end up with entire populations systematically excluded from diagnosis — especially girls, women, and adults, who were invisible under the DSM-IV model not because they lacked neurodivergent traits, but because their struggles did not meet the externally observable threshold.
3. Mutual exclusivity, age thresholds, and the erasure of AuDHD
The insistence in DSM-IV that autism and ADHD could not co-occur compounded these issues significantly. If autism was diagnosed, attentional difficulties were reframed as “part of autism.” If ADHD traits were prominent, autistic traits were often overlooked or misattributed.
This had real consequences. For many people — myself included — referral pathways explicitly ruled out ADHD once an autism diagnosis was made, even when attentional regulation differences were obvious in hindsight. This persisted well after the publication of DSM-5, demonstrating how slowly conceptual change translated into clinical practice.
The strict requirement for symptoms to be present before age 7 further narrowed the diagnostic gate. It assumed:
- Accurate childhood recall
- Attentive adults
- Environments capable of recognising internalised struggle
- A childhood that left documentary evidence of impairment
For individuals whose difficulties were masked, accommodated, or misinterpreted — particularly girls, women, and adults with inattentive ADHD profiles — this threshold alone was enough to invalidate diagnosis.
What later came to be recognised as AuDHD was not newly created by social media or awareness campaigns. It had always existed. It was simply excluded by design. The apparent rise in diagnoses following DSM-5 is better understood not as over-diagnosis, but as delayed recognition of neurotypes that DSM-IV could not see.
4. DSM-5: what actually changed (and why it mattered)
DSM-5 did not suddenly “invent” new neurodevelopmental conditions. What it did — and this is the part that keeps being missed — was change the model. It moved away from a rigid, siloed, impairment-first framework and toward one that better reflected how neurodevelopmental differences actually present across a lifespan and across sexes (Nigg, 2014).
One of the most significant changes was the removal of the mutual exclusivity rule between autism and ADHD. For the first time, it became diagnostically valid to say what many people had been living for decades: that both can exist in the same person, simultaneously, interacting with and amplifying each other (American Professional Society of ADHD and Related Disorders, n.d.).
DSM-5 also reconceived autism spectrum disorders, consolidating multiple subcategories into one spectrum, which reflected evidence that the old subtypes were not reliably distinct and often excluded variations in presentation, particularly in girls and women (Matson, Kozlowski, & Horovitz, 2014).
This wasn’t a softening of standards. It was a correction. And once you correct the model, you don’t just change who gets diagnosed — you change who was previously excluded.
5. ADHD: from behavioural nuisance to neurodevelopmental reality
Under DSM-IV, ADHD was framed largely as a childhood behavioural disorder. Diagnosis hinged on visible impairment, early disruption, and external validation. Adults were largely ignored. Internalised presentations barely registered. And girls? If you weren’t bouncing off classroom walls by age seven, good luck — the system was explicitly calibrated for overt, disruptive behaviours that boys were more likely to display. Many girls quietly struggled, masked their differences, or adapted to expectations, and were therefore invisible to clinicians.
DSM-5 fundamentally changed this. The age-of-onset criterion was raised from before age 7 to before age 12, recognising that ADHD traits do not switch on at a specific birthday, and many people — particularly girls and women with inattentive profiles — cope, mask, or compensate until external demands exceed internal capacity (American Psychiatric Association, 2013).
Crucially, ADHD was firmly positioned as a neurodevelopmental condition, not merely a behavioural one (Nigg, 2014). This matters because it reframes ADHD from “can’t sit still” to differences in executive function, attention regulation, working memory, and cognitive load management — traits that persist into adulthood whether or not they caused trouble in primary school.
6. Neurodivergence, co-morbidity, and the reality of AuDHD
Neurodivergence was not a formal concept in DSM-IV, and ADHD was certainly not treated as part of it. The idea that someone could be both autistic and ADHD simply didn’t fit the taxonomy. Girls and women were doubly disadvantaged: masked autistic traits, internalised ADHD, or mild behavioural disruption were treated as invisible.
DSM-5 didn’t invent AuDHD. It stopped denying its existence (American Professional Society of ADHD and Related Disorders, n.d.).
Adults — many of whom had been misdiagnosed, partially diagnosed, or dismissed entirely — suddenly had a framework that could describe their lived experience coherently. Sensory overload plus hyperfocus. Pattern thinking plus executive dysfunction. Rigidity and novelty-seeking in constant tension. And yes, this included girls and women who had been silently struggling for decades, invisible under the old system.
If you want a reason diagnoses increased, start there. This also explains why many people diagnosed with autism later received an ADHD diagnosis (or vice versa), sometimes years apart. It wasn’t diagnostic inflation. It was diagnostic catch-up, particularly for females whose traits had been masked or misattributed.
7. “Awareness”, social media, and other convenient distractions
“At this point, ‘increased awareness’ is often offered as the primary explanation for rising diagnoses. It’s not wrong — it’s just wildly insufficient. Awareness does not create diagnoses. Criteria do” (American Psychiatric Association, 2013).
Social media didn’t change the DSM. TikTok didn’t rewrite diagnostic manuals. What social platforms did do was give people language for experiences they’d already been having, and the confidence to seek assessment once the system finally allowed for it.
Blaming awareness or social media is convenient because it avoids confronting the real issue: the old model was inadequate, and it systematically excluded women from recognition.
8. So no — this isn’t over-diagnosis. It’s overdue diagnosis
When you put all of this together, the current narrative collapses:
- A classification system changes
- Exclusions are removed
- Age thresholds are adjusted
- Adult presentations are legitimised
- Co-morbidity is acknowledged
- Diagnostic language catches up with lived reality
- Girls and women who were previously invisible are now seen
Suddenly, people who were always there are finally being counted. That isn’t over-diagnosis. That’s what happens when you stop systematically missing people.
9. A personal perspective — why this matters
I’ve deliberately focused here on ADHD, ASD, and AuDHD. Why? Because these are the conditions I know from the inside. I live them. I think in them. I can describe their nuances, their frustrations, their subtle strengths, and their blind spots. I am not speaking from outdated assumptions, second-hand anecdotes, or simplified textbooks. I am speaking from lived experience coupled with decades of observation, reflection, and professional insight.
We are here. We exist. We know our challenges — you’ve never been shy about pointing them out — but we also know our strengths. If those strengths make you rethink what “good” looks like, or make you uncomfortable, perhaps have a nose through DSM-5. There’s probably something in there for you.
Conclusion
So, are neurodivergent conditions being over-diagnosed? No. Not even close. Recognition replaced invisibility. Validation replaced dismissal. Adults, girls, and women who had been overlooked are now visible.
We’ve found our voices, and the system can no longer ignore us. And if that makes you twitch… well, maybe that says more about you than us.
References
American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Publishing. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK519712/
American Professional Society of ADHD and Related Disorders. (n.d.). New diagnostic criteria for ADHD. Retrieved from https://add.org/new-diagnostic-criteria-for-adhd/
Coury, D. L., & McCracken, J. T. (2014). New classification for neurodevelopmental disorders. Current Opinion in Psychiatry, 27(2), 97–102. https://journals.lww.com/co-psychiatry/fulltext/2014/03000/new_classification_for_neurodevelopmental.2.aspx
Matson, J. L., Kozlowski, A. M., & Horovitz, M. (2014). Autism spectrum and neurodevelopmental disorders: Updates and implications. Psychiatric Times. Retrieved from https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/view/autism-spectrum-and-neurodevelopmental-disorders
Nigg, J. T. (2014). Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and lifespan development: DSM-5 updates and considerations. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 5, 1–10. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3955126/
